top of page

To Live, To Act, To Be Remembered: Andrew Scott Shines in "Elsinore"

Writer: Rua Fay
Rua Fay
41 minutes ago
3 min read

2026 has been a year for the books in terms of great on-screen performances. From Primetime to La Bola Negra to the Odyssey, there's only one month left in the year and it feels like the contenders for Best Actor just keep on coming. This week sees the release ofSimon Stone's festival favorite Elsinore starring Andrew Scott who practically cemented his nomination for his performance in a film that is as inspiring as it is heart wrenching.

Based on a true story, Elsinore is about the last few months of Ian Charleson's life in 1989. Rising to fame after starring in two Best-Picture winning films Chariots of Fire and Gandhi, Charleson found himself presented with the role of a lifetime, Hamlet at London's National Theatre. While preparing to star in the world's most famous play about mortality, Charleson must also confront his own, choosing the role over pursuing full treatment of his terminal AIDS diagnosis. Charleson would pass away after seven weeks of playing Hamlet, choosing art over health and in his own words: quality of life over quantity. Led by Andrew Scott, the film also stars Olivia Coleman, Billie Piper, Luke Thompson, and Joe Locke. Premiering at the Telluride Film Festival in September, Elsinore has been making audiences sob since it's first screening.

Films about AIDS are nothing new. While the memories may be fuzzy now, the HIV/AIDS epidemic shook the world in the 80's, wreaking havoc across the globe, most prevalently in the gay community. AIDS robbed the world of an entire generation of artists, inventors, and change-makers, whose suffering was either ignored or celebrated because of their identities. Elsinore makes that pain seem like it happened just yesterday, a heavy reminder of those who lived through the epidemic, and an eye-opening revelation for those born long after.

While Elsinore is full of great performances, writing, cinematography, and all around technical filmmaking, the crown jewel is Andrew Scott's performance as Ian Charleson. Playing any role convincingly is a challenge, but it is increased tenfold when you are portraying a real person and Scott more than delivers. It's easy to see why Scott would want to take the role, probably seeing a lot of himself in Charleson, with Scott even playing Hamlet himself in 2017. He approaches the role with a sense of humanity and authenticity that is downright impossible to describe. With the help of screenwriter, Stephen Beresford, Scott plays Charleson as more than an actor, but a man, a friend, an artist, and most of all, a fighter. While Hamlet may have been Ian Charleson's role of a lifetime, Charleson himself is Scott's.

While the performances in this film are stellar, they were something I expected. What I didn't expect to love so much was the explosive and delightfully theatrical score by Stefan Gregory. It adds so much weight to every scene, making the final act feel as grandiose to the audience as I'm sure it felt for Ian Charleson. I will definitely be looking for it on vinyl when it comes out!

Elsinore's heavy subject matter has drawn criticism for being "Oscar-bait" a relatively new term I have a particular distaste for. Film has existed long before award shows, and all around the globe you will find artists who make film because it is what they love to do, not because they want to be praised for it by an arbitrary committee. While Elsinore does sometimes feel like it is trying to pull on your heartstrings a little too blatantly, I can't help but feel like this film was made to do justice to an unsung hero of the AIDS epidemic who stood strong while facing death in literally every direction. Just because something is a drama does not make it "Oscar-bait," and if you really think so, maybe you just need to watch more movies.

For those who lived through the AIDS epidemic, for those who lost someone, or for those who just want an education in strength against all odds, Elsinore is the perfect film for you.

bottom of page